Is Anyone Else Getting A Serious Case of Déjà Vu?
Alright, let’s be honest. The weeks after WrestleMania are supposed to feel like the first day of school. New bullies, new crushes, new stories. It’s the one time of year WWE gets a hard reset, a chance to reshuffle the deck and throw some fresh paint on a product that can occasionally feel as stale as the popcorn under the bleachers. The post-WrestleMania 41 Raw and SmackDown shows gave us that little buzz, that glimmer of 'what's next?' that we all chase.
And then the Backlash card started filling up. Oh, boy. It’s starting to look less like a bold new chapter and more like a DVD extra of deleted scenes from the main show. The latest additions, as confirmed by the company this week, are a perfect illustration of this creative holding pattern: two immediate rematches that have me wondering if the booking team just hit 'copy-paste' on their April notes.
The Tag Team Traffic Jam We’re Still Stuck In
First up, we have the WWE Tag Team Champions, A-Town Down Under, defending against the perpetually snakebitten #DIY. This isn't a bad match on paper. In fact, it’s guaranteed to be a banger. You’ve got four of the best pure workers in the company. But that’s not the issue. The issue is that we just saw this. Their clash at WrestleMania 41 was part of the big spectacle, and now, just a few weeks later, we're running it back with no new stakes, no fresh angle, just... more.
For Grayson Waller and Austin Theory, it’s a chance to cement their reign. They are the human embodiment of a smarmy Instagram comment section, and they are brilliant at it. They probably cheated to win at 'Mania, and they'll probably try to cheat again. That's their whole vibe. They’re the villains who succeed just enough to make you furious. A win at Backlash against guys as beloved as Gargano and Ciampa would be massive heat. But it also feels predictable.
The real tragedy here might be #DIY. Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa are the patron saints of 'almost'. Their story is the stuff of indie wrestling legend, a Shakespearean drama of friendship and betrayal played out in VFW halls and Full Sail arenas. But on the main roster, they’ve been spinning their wheels. Another loss here, even a valiant one, pushes them further into that 'good hand' territory that is death for anyone with main event aspirations. When do they finally win the big one? Or, and this is the more terrifying question, what if they never do? This match feels less like a crowning moment and more like another opportunity for heroic failure, a trope that is wearing dangerously thin for the DIY faithful.
The Problem With Instant Replays
My beef isn't with the wrestlers; it's with the booking. Where’s the chase? Instead of #DIY having to scratch and claw their way back to a title shot over a month or two, beating other teams and rebuilding their case, they're just handed a rematch. It cheapens the WrestleMania victory for Theory and Waller and makes #DIY look less like resilient underdogs and more like guys who just got to cut the line because the story was convenient. This is a pay-per-view match that feels like it could have been a hot TV main event, used to build a bigger story for a bigger show down the line.
LA Knight's First Hurdle Is A Familiar One
The second match added to the card is LA Knight defending his newly won United States Championship against the man he took it from, Santos Escobar. YEAH. We all went nuts when Knight finally got his moment, grabbing that title on the SmackDown after WrestleMania. It was overdue, it was earned, and the pop was deafening. He is, without a doubt, one of the most organically over stars the company has had in a decade. And that’s exactly why this match is so terrifying.
This is his first premium live event defense. It’s a test. Not for him, but for the company. Do they know what they have in LA Knight? Do they understand that this isn’t just a flash in the pan? The first title defense for a white-hot babyface is arguably more important than the title win itself. It sets the tone for the entire reign. A strong, decisive victory tells the world that this is the new standard. A loss, or even a non-finish, is a catastrophic momentum killer.
And that's where Santos Escobar comes in. He’s a fantastic heel—smooth, vicious, and backed by a crew that gives him a constant numbers advantage. But his main roster booking has been inconsistent. He's a threat, but is he a 'take the title right back' level of threat? A loss for Knight here would be a booking blunder of epic proportions. It would immediately frame him as a transitional champ, a guy who got a token run to sell a few t-shirts before dropping the belt back to a 'company guy'. It reeks of the kind of booking that plagued guys like Zack Ryder. We all saw that trainwreck happen in slow motion, and nobody wants a sequel.
The Real Danger Isn't Escobar, It's WWE's Own History
The critical observation here is that WWE has a long and storied history of getting cold feet. They build a guy up, the crowd goes wild, and then Vince McMahon—or whoever is steering the ship these days—decides they don't 'get it' and pulls the plug. LA Knight feels like the ultimate fan-driven project. His success is a direct rebuke of the idea that the company has to force-feed stars to the audience. This first defense against Escobar isn’t just a match; it’s a statement of intent from WWE. If they fumble this, they risk alienating a huge portion of the audience that is desperate to believe in a new star. Don't screw this up. YEAH!
Is This Lazy Booking Or Just... The Way It Is?
Look, there's a logic to the 'WrestleMania Rematch' phenomenon. The stories are already in place, the rivalries are hot, and it gives a casual viewer who only watched 'Mania a familiar entry point to the next PLE. It's safe. It's easy. It eats up a month of booking without having to invent anything new. But 'safe' and 'easy' don't create legendary moments. Backlash, in its best form, is about chaos. It's about the unpredictable consequences of the biggest show of the year.
Instead, the 2026 edition is shaping up to be an echo. A highlight reel of last month's biggest hits. The wrestling will be great, of that I have no doubt. Waller, Theory, Gargano, Ciampa, Knight, and Escobar are all incapable of having a bad match. But will it be memorable? Will we be talking about these matches in six months? Or will they just be well-executed filler before the summer programs kick into high gear? Right now, Backlash feels less like a must-see event and more like a contractual obligation. It's the show after the show, and unfortunately, it's starting to feel like it.
Read Next
- WWE Backlash sets the stage for a brutal month of May
- Nashville is buying WrestleMania with a 3.5 million dollar risk
- The Reigns vs. Fatu dynamic is a ticking time bomb
- Drew McIntyre's WWE absence is the smartest booking decision of the year
- 🏆 WrestleMania 41 — Full Coverage Hub
- 💥 WWE Backlash 2026 — Full Coverage Hub