TACTICAL ANALYSIS

Bully Ray is right about CM Punk and Cody Rhodes on SmackDown

Jul 28, 2026 Analysis
Share

Pour one out for high-stakes promos

Grab a beer and sit down. We need to talk about what happened on SmackDown between CM Punk and Cody Rhodes because Bully Ray hit the nail on the head. It was filler, pure and simple, when it should have been absolute fire.

When you put the two biggest babyfaces of this era in the same ring, you expect magic. Instead, we got a polite tea party that felt completely disconnected from the intensity both guys usually bring to the table.

Bully Ray nailed it on Busted Open Radio. When CM Punk and Cody Rhodes stand nose-to-nose, the building should feel like it's about to explode. Friday night felt more like a scheduled contract reading for a suburban homeowner association.

The lost art of the main event confrontation

Cast your mind back to classic rivalries. When Stone Cold Steve Austin crossed paths with The Rock in early 2001, nobody was handing out complimentary verbal pats on the back. They stared holes through each other because the WWE Championship meant more than life itself.

Here, Cody and Punk acted like old college roommates catching up at a weekend tailgate. Where was the tension? Where was the subtle desperation from two guys who both desperately want to be the undisputed alpha of the industry?

Punk is at his absolute best when he has an edge, scratching at the establishment like a rabid dog. Cody is standard-bearer royalty who thrives when defending his turf. Having them trade generic compliments for seven minutes flatline-tested the crowd's energy real fast.

Even legends miss the mark sometimes

Look, nobody is saying Cody Rhodes and CM Punk suddenly forgot how to work. Cody's title run has delivered stellar matches, and Punk's promo work over the past year has given us some all-time great television. But that is precisely why this segment hurt to watch.

The creative team dropped the ball by giving them zero stakes to fight over in that moment. Without a clear catalyst, two master mic workers were reduced to exchanging pleasantries that belonged on a preshow podcast rather than primetime television.

If you're not going to let them tear into each other's motivations, don't put them out there together. Keep them separated until you're ready to press the nuclear button and set the canvas on fire.

Fix the script before the spark dies out

Pro wrestling operates on friction. Without heat, even the shine of gold championship belts starts to look dull under the arena lights. Bully Ray called it filler because we all recognized the holding pattern in real-time.

We know what these two can do when the leash comes off. Remember Punk's feud with Drew McIntyre? Every single second felt like somebody was genuinely going to end up in an ambulance. That is the standard.

WWE has all the momentum in the world right now, but coasting on star power alone is a dangerous game. Next time Cody and Punk share a microphone, skip the lovefest and let the sparks fly.

WWE Elite Collection Series 108 - CM Punk Action Figure

The Best in the World, immortalized in premium plastic.

$22.99 View Deal

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did the CM Punk and Cody Rhodes promo on SmackDown fall flat?
The segment lacked intensity and stakes, feeling more like a polite conversation than a high-stakes confrontation. The lack of friction or conflict between two major babyfaces resulted in a segment that failed to match the energy expected from stars of their magnitude.
What did Bully Ray say about the SmackDown segment?
Bully Ray labeled the interaction between CM Punk and Cody Rhodes as filler on Busted Open Radio. He noted that despite their star power, the segment felt disconnected and lacked the necessary tension that should exist when two top talents stand face-to-face.
How should a top-tier WWE confrontation feel?
Effective main event confrontations should feel like the arena is about to explode with palpable tension. The article suggests that legends should demonstrate desperation and genuine conflict rather than exchanging generic, polite compliments.
What was missing from the Cody Rhodes and CM Punk interaction?
The segment suffered from a lack of a clear catalyst or stakes for the stars to fight over. By failing to lean into their motivations or create friction, the creative team reduced two master mic workers to exchanging pleasantries that lacked the necessary heat.
How can WWE improve future promos involving Cody Rhodes and CM Punk?
The article suggests that WWE leadership should skip the pleasantries and allow the wrestlers to tear into each other's motivations to create genuine friction. Keeping the stars separated until there is a high-stakes story to tell will prevent them from coasting on star power alone.

More Coverage